2021 Award Timeline
March 1st – Player Submission Opens
March 12th @ 11:59 p.m. – Player Submission Closes
March 15th – Player Watch List Released
May 1st – Final Player List Released
May 26th – Winner Announced
| Player Name | Player Grade | High School | Coach’s Name |
| Justin Bultemieier | n/a | Adams Central | Dave Nuenschwander |
| Chase Murray | n/a | Adams Central | Dave Nuenschwander |
| Alex Currie | n/a | Adams Central | Dave Nuenschwander |
| Blake Heyerly | n/a | Adams Central | Dave Nuenschwander |
| Tanner Hirn | 12 | Bellmont HS | Tom Montgomery |
| Tyler James | 12 | Bellmont HS | Tom Montgomery |
| Kobe Baker | 11 | Bellmont HS | Tom Montgomery |
| Magnuss Lee | 11 | Bellmont HS | Tom Montgomery |
| Ethan Garner | 11 | Bellmont HS | Tom Montgomery |
| Trevor Walker | 11 | Bellmont HS | Tom Montgomery |
| Brenden Lytle | 12 | Bishop Dwenger | Jason Garrett |
| Sam Pesa | 12 | Bishop Dwenger | Jason Garrett |
| Callan Stauffer | 12 | Bishop Dwenger | Jason Garrett |
| Xavier Nolan | 12 | Bishop Dwenger | Jason Garrett |
| Jack Tippmann | 11 | Bishop Dwenger | Jason Garrett |
| Brayton Thomas | 9 | Bishop Dwenger | Jason Garrett |
| Beau Jacquay | 11 | Bishop Dwenger | Jason Garrett |
| Lukas North | 12 | Bishop Luers | Jeff Stanski |
| Jerod Handshoe | 12 | Carroll High School | Dave Ginder |
| Cameron Niedens | 12 | Carroll High School | Dave Ginder |
| Alex Smith | 11 | Carroll High School | Dave Ginder |
| Conner Miller | 12 | Carroll High School | Dave Ginder |
| Josh Kuhns | 12 | Carroll High School | Dave Ginder |
| Jaycob McCullough | 12 | Carroll High School | Dave Ginder |
| Brayten Gordon | 12 | Churubusco | Jordan Turner |
| Evan Snyder | 12 | Churubusco | Jordan Turner |
| Keenan Hendricks | 11 | Churubusco | Jordan Turner |
| Callahan Ostrowski | 11 | Churubusco | Jordan Turner |
| Seth Abel | 12 | Churubusco | Jordan Turner |
| Sam Gladd | 11 | Columbia City High School | Rob Bell |
| Adin Miller | 11 | Columbia City High School | Rob Bell |
| Preston Henschen | 12 | Columbia City High School | Rob Bell |
| Steele Jackson | 12 | DeKalb HS | Tim Murdock |
| Brayden Risedorph | 11 | East Noble | Aaron Desmonds |
| Owen Willard | 11 | Eastside | Aaron Willard |
| Dylan Herig | 12 | Eastside | Aaron Willard |
| Wade Miller | 12 | Eastside | Aaron Willard |
| Jack Buchanan | 11 | Eastside | Aaron Willard |
| Gage Smith | 12 | Garrett High School | Jason Richards |
| Trey Richards | 11 | Garrett High School | Jason Richards |
| Graham Kelham | 11 | Garrett High School | Jason Richards |
| Dalton Wasson | 11 | Heritage Jr./Sr. High School | Dean Lehrman |
| Carter Mathison | 12 | Homestead | Nick Byall |
| Luke Palmer | 12 | Homestead | Nick Byall |
| Kaleb Kolpien | 12 | Homestead | Nick Byall |
| Graham Kollen | 12 | Homestead | Nick Byall |
| Grant Simmons | 12 | Homestead | Nick Byall |
| Cole Elkins | 12 | Homestead | Nick Byall |
| Jayden Lepper | 12 | Homestead | Nick Byall |
| Tyler Papenbrock | 12 | Leo | Gary Rogers |
| Coley Stevens | 12 | Leo | Gary Rogers |
| Damien Gudakunst | 12 | Leo | Gary Rogers |
| Quinten Peters | 12 | Leo | Gary Rogers |
| Gannon Brown | 12 | Leo | Gary Rogers |
| Michael O’Brien | 12 | Leo | Gary Rogers |
| Dakota Patterson | 12 | Leo | Gary Rogers |
| Jacob Kortenber | 12 | New Haven | Dave Bischoff |
| Augie Difederico | 12 | New Haven | Dave Bischoff |
| Tarron White | 12 | Northrop | Matt Brumbaugh |
| Luke Siren | 11 | Northrop | Matt Brumbaugh |
| Rocco Hanes | 12 | Norwell High School | Dave Goodmiller |
| Eli Riley | 12 | Norwell High School | Dave Goodmiller |
| Adam Besser | 12 | South Adams High School | Brad Buckingham |
| James Arnold | 12 | South Adams High School | Brad Buckingham |
| AJ Dull | 11 | South Adams High School | Brad Buckingham |
| Conner Young | 11 | South Adams High School | Brad Buckingham |
| Tanner Johnson | 12 | Southern Wells | Blade Rheinhart |
| Bryce Tucker | 12 | Whitko Jr/Sr High | Jorell Tucker |
| Evan Wilson | 12 | Whitko Jr/Sr High | Jorell Tucker |
Award History
2019 – Grant Besser – South Adams High School
2020 – Canceled due to pandemic
2021 –